Culture

Casting Call: Chad Harbach's The Art of Fielding

Welcome to Signature's Casting Call, where we exercise our creative muscles by focusing our attention on extraordinary characters from exceptional books - either fiction or nonfiction - and make the case for how we'd cast those roles if given the chance. Note that, here at Signature, we're not casting directors, nor are we producers, agents, or anyone else who has any say in how a film will be cast; we're simply ardent fans of books and movies who can't help ourselves from such musings.

Chad Harbach's debut, The Art of Fielding, is not just a baseball story, but rather a coming-of-age novel about the volatility of love and friendship. Harbach tackles these subjects without tired cliches, managing to breathe new life into familiar tropes. The story focuses on the lives of five characters: Henry Skrimshander, the unassuming, small-town kid from Lankton, South Dakota who quickly becomes the star player of his college team, the Westish Harpooners; Mike Schwartz, the physically massive, beating heart of Harbach's work; Owen Dunne, Henry's ethereal, erudite roommate; Pella Affenlight, a waif who comes to Westish to escape a failed marriage, only to find and fall for Schwartz; and Guert Affenlight, a Melville scholar, the school's President, Pella's largely absent father, and he's a real looker.

When we first meet Henry, he is described as "the smallest player on the field, a scrawny novelty of a shortstop," but Schwartz sees Henry's potential and decides to take him under his oversized wing so that Henry might see it, too. Within no time, Henry is set to tie the N.C.A.A. record for consecutive errorless games by a shortstop (a record held by his childhood baseball hero Aparicio Rodriguez). With the major league scouts watching from the stands, time stands still for a moment as the fates of all five characters shift dramatically.

Harbach's character portraits, throughout the novel, are so vivid, it's hard not to imagine the book being adapted for the screen. Unsurprisingly, there have been talks of an HBO series, produced by Scott Rudin.

Anton Yelchin is a natural for the role of Henry Skrimshander. The actor, who starred in Drake Doremus's 2011 film "Like Crazy" and will be playing Pavel Chekov in J. J. Abrams's upcoming "Star Trek" sequel, has proven he's a capable lead, immensely and innately likable, but reserved and inwardly complex. He's somebody for whom we'd certainly root.

Though he does stand tall at 6'3", Liam Hemsworth isn't Mike Schwartz at first blush. Tack on a couple of pounds and some scruffier facial hair, and suddenly, he's our guy. He has a tangible warmth about him.

There's something literary about Mia Wasikowska, who has previously assumed the titular roles in "Jane Eyre" and "Alice in Wonderland." The actress's enduring subtlety compliments Pella Affenlight, just as Pella's spontaneity might complement Wasikowska.

He may be one of Hollywood's most selective actors, but Daniel Day-Lewis, time and time again, proves he can do just about anything. President Guert Affenlight is one of the most interesting characters in Harbach's novel. He is a sophisticate and scholar, the college president and staple campus presence. Affenlight falls in love with Owen Dunne and engages in a secret romance with the student. It would take someone like Daniel Day-Lewis, an actor with not just the ability, but also the dedication, to adopt a character like Affenlight. And he's a real looker.

Conspicuously absent is Henry's roommate, the indelible Owen Dunne. He is the kind of character you only meet in books. Let us know who you think might play Owen in the comments section below.

  • D

    When I read books I always try and picture the characters as actors. Call it lack of imagination but movies are my first love and I prefer a concrete image of a character when I'm reading. When I read the Art of Fielding this is who I pictured.

    President Affenlight: Clooney
    Pella Affenlight: Amber Heard
    Schwartz: Liam Hemsworth
    Skrimshander: Logan Lerman
    Owen: Michael B. Jordan

  • Rick

    I agree that this book begs to be made into a movie. I disagree that Liam Hemsworth fits the part of Mike Schwartz. The Schwartz character is Jewish, extremely hairy all over, stocky, and a catcher. I don't have a suggestion as to who would make the perfect Schwartzie, but I just don't see Hemsworth doing the part justice.

  • Alaska

    I always imagined Mike Falzone when reading the character Schwartz. I know he's not an actor but I he seemed to fit the whole description perfectly - google him.

  • Z

    I know hes way to old but a guy like mark ruffalo comes to mind for schwartz. Hes short and really hairy

  • bee

    If Liam Hemsworth shouldn't play Schwartz because he isn't Jewish, then Logan Lerman and Anton Yelchin certainly should not play Skrimshander, because they are Jewish, and Skrimshander is not.

  • Steve

    I've liked all the comments on characters - as for Pella, I thought about Scar Jo!

  • mary margaret

    For Owen, someone like Alex Wyndham

  • Daan

    Donald Glover would be a good Owen

  • Paul

    Schoolio
    Here's my casting idea -

    Schwartz: Channing Tatum
    Henry: Freddie Highmore
    Pella: Greta Gerwig
    Owen: Donald Glover
    Guert: Chris Cooper
    Sophie Skrimshander: Rachel Bilson
    Coach Cox: Paul Giamatti

    So do you like my casting?

  • A

    As I read the book, I keep thinking of Andrew Garfield as Owen.

  • http://helenehsblog.blogspot.com Helene

    Pella - Hannah Ware
    Owen - Jaime Cepero

  • Sarah

    Henry: Dylan O'Brien!

  • seth

    I have been so obsessed with finding the right (albeit esoteric) home for logging the absolute best inspiration for casting the character Owen, that I have been relentlessly bugging friends until I found this forum.

    Owen's character was MADE FOR Max Greenfield... the dude who plays Schmidt on "New Girl"... who's that girl... it's Jess!

  • Justin

    I would make the perfect Owen Dunne. Legit the character is me and I am an actor.

Like What You're Reading? Get the best of Signature, delivered to your inbox every week. Join the Signature newsletter